Ethics & scope
L’énoncé ci-dessous est le même texte que dans le dépôt. Aucune étude n’est en cours. Une étude ultérieure aurait besoin de son propre examen éthique et d’un consentement distinct.
# Ethics statement No study is running on this questionnaire. Answers are not evaluated for research, not aggregated across people, and not published. The questionnaire is a tool for self-reflection. A person may save their own answers only with explicit consent, so they can open them again later or on another device. A later study would need its own ethics review and its own, separate consent. That consent is not part of this questionnaire. The model comes from open research in the [Cognitive Landscape Research Programme (CLRP)](https://github.com/SynapticFour/cognitive-landscape-research-programme). Using the questionnaire does not enrol anyone in that programme and does not ask them to contribute data to it. > **Normative programme commitment:** [CLRP-007: Non-Diagnostic Commitment](https://github.com/SynapticFour/cognitive-landscape-research-programme/blob/clrp-v2026.1/clrp/CLRP-007-non-diagnostic-commitment.md). This document adds the questionnaire's own limits: consent, what is stored, and what the result is not. ## Overview The Perceptual & Cognitive Mapping System (PCMS) is a questionnaire for self-reflection. This document states the limits that apply to that use. ## Critical Non-Diagnostic Clarification ### NOT A MEDICAL OR CLINICAL TOOL - **Self-reflection**: PCMS shows a person their own answers. It is not a study. - **No Diagnostic Claims**: The system does not diagnose, treat, or assess medical conditions - **No Clinical Recommendations**: Results are not medical advice and should not replace professional healthcare - **Label-Free Approach**: Uses dimensional modeling rather than categorical labels or diagnoses ### Appropriate Use Cases - **Self-Understanding**: Personal insight into cognitive patterns and preferences - **Not a study**: A future study would need its own ethics review and a separate consent. This questionnaire is not that study. - **Educational**: Understanding different cognitive styles and approaches - **Personal Development**: Identifying optimal environments and strategies ### Inappropriate Use Cases - **Medical Diagnosis**: Cannot be used for diagnosing ADHD, autism, or other conditions - **Clinical Decision Making**: Not suitable for treatment planning or medical decisions - **Employment Screening**: Not designed for hiring or employment decisions - **Educational Placement**: Not appropriate for special education eligibility, streaming, or high-stakes tracking ## Non-Gatekeeping Guarantee PCMS results: - **Do not** affect eligibility for any formal diagnostic assessment - **Do not** serve as evidence for or against any clinical determination - **Do not** replace any occupational, educational, or healthcare assessment - **Are not** designed to be shown to institutions as evidence of cognitive traits If any deployment of PCMS is found to be used as a gatekeeper to clinical assessment, that deployment violates the terms of this project's ethical guidelines. If research data is collected, the operator of that deployment is responsible for reporting it through whatever ethics review process that institution actually has. This repository does not name such a board. Any fork or derivative of PCMS that uses results to influence access to services must remove PCMS branding and clearly distinguish its use case. ### Classroom, youth, and international deployment - **Default product consent** in this repository assumes **adult** participants unless your fork changes it. Use with **children or adolescents** (for example a middle-school class) requires **institutional ethical approval**, **parental/guardian consent and/or pupil assent** following local law and school policy, and usually a **separate build** (age text, data retention, teacher vs self-paced flow). - **Research (e.g. PhD) and cross-country use** are supported technically by pseudonymous storage and dimensional (non-label) reporting, but **each jurisdiction and institution** remains responsible for lawful basis, information sheets, and whether results may be shown in group settings. - **Language and examples** in `messages/*.json` aim for plain, non-stigmatising wording; all translated strings should be checked by **fluent local reviewers** for cultural fit (including Wolof and Twi/Akan paths in `docs/I18N.md`). ## Core Ethical Principles ### 1. Respect for Persons **Autonomy and Informed Consent** - All participation is fully voluntary - Comprehensive consent process with clear information disclosure - Right to withdraw at any time without penalty - Ongoing consent throughout the assessment process **Dignity and Respect** - No stigmatizing language or labels - Emphasis on cognitive diversity as natural variation - Respect for individual differences and cultural backgrounds - Avoidance of deficit-based framing ### 2. Beneficence **Maximizing Benefits** - Designed for self-understanding and personal growth - Provides actionable insights for cognitive optimization - Does not collect answers for a study - Free and accessible to all users **Minimizing Risks** - No medical or diagnostic claims - Clear boundaries about system capabilities - Protection against misinterpretation of results - Resources for professional support when needed ### 3. Justice **Equitable Access** - Free of charge for all users - No socioeconomic barriers to participation - Culturally adaptive assessment approaches - Multiple language support (English, German, Wolof; Twi/Akan draft with English fallback — extend as needed) **Fair Distribution** - The questionnaire is free to use for self-reflection - Open-source tools for people who want to read the model - Community involvement in system development - Inclusive design processes ### 4. Privacy and Confidentiality **Data Protection** - Pseudonymous session data (no direct personal identifiers in the assessment flow) - Transport is HTTPS/TLS. The application does not encrypt answer payloads end-to-end before upload. When optional cloud storage is enabled, the database provider encrypts stored data at rest. Responsible: the operator of that deployment. - Access control beyond the provider defaults is not described as a completed audit in this repository. - A completed security audit is not recorded here. Responsible: the repository operator. **Data Usage** - No study use. Saved answers are not evaluated for research, not aggregated across people, and not published. - A person may save their own answers, with consent, only to open them again. - Right to delete those answers, and to download their own export. ## Informed Consent Process ### Consent Components 1. **Purpose Disclosure** - Clear explanation of the self-reflection purpose - Description of cognitive mapping approach - Expected benefits and limitations - Time commitment and process overview 2. **Procedures Information** - Assessment process description - Data collection methods - Question types and response formats - Estimated completion time 3. **Risks and Benefits** - Minimal risk assessment - Potential benefits for self-understanding - Limitations of the system - Alternative assessment options 4. **Confidentiality Measures** - Pseudonymous storage when a person chooses to save; nothing is stored as anonymous once a session identifier exists - Data storage and protection - No publication of answers and no aggregation across people - Contact information for concerns 5. **Voluntary Participation** - Right to withdraw without penalty - Ability to skip questions - Data deletion upon withdrawal - No impact on any services ### Consent Implementation **Digital Consent Process** - Multi-step consent interface - Comprehension checks - Explicit agreement checkboxes - Timestamped consent records **Ongoing Consent** - Progress indicators throughout assessment - Option to withdraw at any point - Clear withdrawal mechanisms - Confirmation of withdrawal completion ### Implemented application behaviour (current build) These items map the principles above to routes and storage in this repository: - **Dedicated consent** — Users complete a **multi-step** flow at **`/consent`** with explicit checkboxes; questionnaire and results redirect here if consent is missing. Details are stored in browser storage (e.g. consent timestamp key used with Supabase session rows). - **Results assent** — Before showing scores, the results surface can require an additional **assent** acknowledgement (see results UI and `messages/*` keys). - **Delete my data** — **`POST /api/delete-session`** removes that person's server-side rows when they present the restore secret and the server role is configured. - **Ethics audit** — **`POST /api/ethics-audit`** can record non-PII events for that person's own session. The production deployment does not serve **`GET /api/ethics/compliance-report`**. - **Internationalization** — Consent and ethics copy are localized via **`messages/*.json`**; Twi strings remain draft for native-speaker review (see `docs/I18N.md`). ## Data Protection Framework ### Pseudonymization Strategy **No PII Collection** - No names, emails, or personal identifiers - No IP addresses stored in raw form - No geolocation data - No device fingerprinting **Session-Based Tracking** - Pseudonymous session IDs - Temporary data storage - Automatic data cleanup - No cross-session tracking **Data Minimization** - Only the answers needed to show the person's own result - Question responses and timing only - No behavioral tracking beyond assessment - No third-party analytics or tracking ### Security Measures **Technical Protection** - HTTPS/TLS for data in transit - Provider encryption at rest when a cloud database is used (not application-level end-to-end encryption) - Regular security updates are an operator duty. This repository does not record that they have been completed. - Access logging and monitoring are not recorded as a completed control here. **Administrative Controls** - Role-based access permissions - Data access audit trails - Regular security reviews - Incident response procedures **Data Retention** - Defined retention periods - Automatic data deletion - Deletion on request, and a scheduled deletion 12 months after saving when the cron secret is set - Compliance with regulations ## Risk Assessment and Mitigation ### Potential Risks **Psychological Risks** - Anxiety about cognitive profile results - Over-interpretation of dimensional scores - Unintended self-labeling - Comparison with others **Privacy Risks** - Data breach potential - Re-identification through pattern analysis - Unauthorized data access - Cross-platform data correlation **Social Risks** - Misunderstanding the result as a diagnosis or as a study - Inappropriate sharing of results - Stigma from cognitive profile - Discrimination concerns ### Mitigation Strategies **Psychological Mitigation** - Clear communication about system limitations - Emphasis on cognitive diversity and growth - Resources for professional support - Balanced presentation of strengths and challenges **Privacy Mitigation** - Encryption in this codebase is HTTPS/TLS in transit and provider encryption at rest. End-to-end encryption of payloads is not implemented. Responsible: the repository operator. - A completed security audit is not recorded in this repository. - Limited data collection scope - Transparency about data usage **Social Mitigation** - Educational materials about cognitive diversity - Clear non-diagnostic positioning - Guidelines for appropriate result sharing - Community engagement and education ## Cultural Considerations ### Cross-Cultural Ethics **Cultural Adaptation** - Contextually appropriate question framing - Cultural validation of assessment items - Translation and localization processes - Cultural advisory board input: not recorded. No such board is listed in this repository. **Global Equity** - Free access regardless of location - Low-bandwidth optimization - Mobile-friendly interfaces - Multiple language support **Respect for Diversity** - Avoidance of Western-centric assumptions - Inclusive cognitive model development - Cultural sensitivity in result interpretation - Community-specific recommendations ## Research Ethics Compliance ### Regulatory Framework **International Standards** - Declaration of Helsinki compliance: not done for this deployment. No Helsinki review is recorded in this repository. Responsible: the lead researcher (`docs/RESEARCH_ACTION_PLAN.md`, section 0.2). - UNESCO Universal Declaration on Bioethics: not recorded as a completed review. - International Conference on Harmonization guidelines: not recorded as a completed review. - GDPR: the in-app privacy notice is the operator-facing processing summary. See [`docs/DEPLOYMENT-LEGAL.md`](./DEPLOYMENT-LEGAL.md) and `/privacy` (`messages/*/privacy.json`). This document does not claim that a supervisory authority has reviewed the deployment. **Institutional Review** - IRB/REC approval: not done. `docs/RESEARCH_ACTION_PLAN.md` marks "IRB approval for human subjects research" as not done. A protocol is planned, not filed here. Responsible: the lead researcher. - Ongoing ethical review: not done. No completed review record is in this repository. - Community advisory boards: not established in this repository. - Stakeholder engagement: not recorded as a completed process. ### Publication Ethics **Responsible Dissemination** - Peer-reviewed publication process - Transparent methodology reporting - Limitations and biases disclosure - Open data sharing policies **Participant Protection** - No individual results in publications - Aggregated data only - Participant pseudonymity guaranteed (no direct personal identifiers in the assessment flow) - Right to review publications ## Monitoring and Oversight ### Ethical Review Processes **Regular Audits** - Annual ethical review: not done. No review date is recorded. - Security audit: not recorded as completed. - Participant feedback collection: not recorded as a completed programme. - Compliance verification: not done. **Advisory Structures** - Ethics advisory board: not established. This repository has no membership list and no appointment. - Community representatives: not recorded as an appointed body. - Cultural consultants: not recorded as an appointed body. - Disability advocates: not recorded as an appointed body. Responsible for IRB preparation: the lead researcher in `docs/RESEARCH_ACTION_PLAN.md`. Responsible for what a running site stores: the operator of that deployment. **Continuous Improvement** - Participant feedback integration - Ethical framework updates - Best practice incorporation - Emerging issue monitoring ## Incident Response ### Data Breach Protocol **Immediate Response** - System isolation and protection - Impact assessment initiation - Regulatory notification (if required) - Participant communication plan **Follow-up Actions** - Security enhancement implementation - Process review and improvement - Additional training if needed - Documentation and reporting ### Ethical Concerns Process **Reporting Mechanisms** - Clear contact information - Multiple reporting channels - Anonymous reporting options - Response time guarantees **Resolution Process** - Concern acknowledgment - Investigation procedures - Resolution communication - Process improvement ## Future Ethical Considerations ### Emerging Technologies **AI and Machine Learning** - Algorithmic bias monitoring - Transparent AI decision-making - Human oversight requirements - Fairness and equity assessments **Advanced Analytics** - Privacy-preserving analytics - Differential privacy implementation - Secure multi-party computation - Federated learning approaches ### Expanding Scope **Clinical Integration** - Clear boundary maintenance - Professional collaboration guidelines - Referral protocol development - Ethical use frameworks **Global Expansion** - Cultural adaptation ethics - Regulatory compliance across jurisdictions - Equity in access and benefit - Community engagement models ## Conclusion This document states the project's intended limits: non-diagnostic use, consent before the questionnaire, and pseudonymous assessment data. It is not a record that an ethics board has approved the deployment. This framework is a living document. A regular ethics review has not been completed. Updates belong with the lead researcher and the repository operator. They are not evidence that an oversight body has signed off. ## Related documents - [CLRP-007 Non-Diagnostic Commitment](https://github.com/SynapticFour/cognitive-landscape-research-programme/blob/clrp-v2026.1/clrp/CLRP-007-non-diagnostic-commitment.md) — normative programme commitment - [`VALIDATION_PROTOCOL.md`](./VALIDATION_PROTOCOL.md) — pointer to [CLRP-VR-2026-001](https://github.com/SynapticFour/cognitive-landscape-research-programme/blob/clrp-v2026.2/validation/CLRP-VR-2026-001-pcms-instrument-status.md) - CLM [`ethics.md`](../../cognitive-landscape-model/docs/ethics.md) — library integrator notes --- **Contact**: For ethical concerns, use the contact address in the site footer. This repository does not name an ethics advisory board. **Review schedule**: An annual ethical review is not done. No review date is recorded. **Version**: 1.0. The status lines above describe the repository as of the privacy and ethics correction. They are not a certificate. ## Stand dieser Punkte (Deutsch) Die folgenden Sätze gelten für dieselbe Codebasis. Sie ersetzen keine abgeschlossene Prüfung. - Transport: HTTPS/TLS. Die Anwendung verschlüsselt Antwortinhalte nicht Ende-zu-Ende vor dem Upload. Wenn die optionale Cloud-Speicherung an ist, verschlüsselt der Datenbankbetreiber gespeicherte Daten im Ruhezustand. Verantwortlich: der Betreiber der jeweiligen Instanz. - Deklaration von Helsinki: nicht erfolgt. In diesem Repository ist keine Helsinki-Prüfung festgehalten. Verantwortlich: die in `docs/RESEARCH_ACTION_PLAN.md`, Abschnitt 0.2, genannte Forschungsleitung. - IRB/REC-Freigabe: nicht erfolgt. Der Aktionsplan markiert die Freigabe für Forschung mit Menschen als nicht erledigt. Ein Protokoll ist geplant, hier nicht eingereicht. Verantwortlich: die Forschungsleitung. - Ethikbeirat: nicht eingerichtet. Keine Mitgliederliste und keine Berufung in diesem Repository. - Jährliche Ethikprüfung: nicht erfolgt. Kein Prüfungsdatum ist festgehalten. - Eine abgeschlossene Sicherheitsprüfung ist hier nicht festgehalten. **Kontakt**: Anfragen an die Adresse in der Fußzeile der Website. Dieses Repository benennt keinen Ethikbeirat.